Architectural ironmongers make robust challenge to fire door testing proposals

Latest News Mon, Mar 27, 2023 5:37 AM

The Guild of Architectural Ironmongers (GAI) has strongly challenged new UK Government proposals for fire door testing.

The proposals from the Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities (DLUHC) would remove the national classification system for construction products – BS 476 – and instead require classification to the British Standard version of the European Standard EN 13501, with testing to EN 1634 test standards becoming the new norm.

In its consultation response, the GAI argued that there is no evidence to suggest that this change will make fire doors any safer. It will, however, have significant impacts throughout the architectural ironmongery and construction sectors.

The removal of assessments of products which can be fitted to fire doors will contribute to reduced interchangeability of fire door hardware, inevitably leading to product shortages and delays. The multi-million-pound cost of retesting thousands of products is among a number of factors that would create competitive advantages for large global door manufacturers at the expense of specialist UK hardware businesses.

Reduced export opportunities and increased reliance on overseas products would in turn lead to a substantial loss of British jobs and expertise. Price rises as a result of these changes also introduce the risk of value-engineering and reduced specification – and therefore greater safety risk – on fire doors.

GAI chief executive Simon Forrester says: “We believe that in its current form, this proposal will cause immense damage to the UK’s world-class architectural ironmongery sector, and problems throughout the architectural and construction sectors, while failing to deliver any meaningful benefits.

“BS 476 – or more specifically, part 22 of that standard – has successfully delivered robust safety assurances for timber fire door users for many years and is still widely recognised as fit for purpose. Indeed, post-Grenfell, testing volumes have increased even further in response to the demand for more primary test evidence.

“Among our members are companies that have spent hundreds of thousands of pounds on this testing this year, with similar amounts budgeted for next year and beyond. One of our members has cited that its business alone has more than 600 BS 476 part 22 tests which will become redundant if the proposed changes go ahead.

“With the cost of each typical fire test up to £11,000, and current waiting times at six months or more for each test, and then another six months for the report, retesting would cause huge disruption throughout the hardware and construction sectors, and cost the industry many millions of pounds – a cost which would have to be passed on to developers and ultimately the consumer.”

The GAI’s consultation response concludes: “We do not believe that there is any evidence to suggest that moving to classification in EN 13501 will make fire doors any safer or deliver any meaningful life safety benefits… We urge the Government to retain the acceptance of classification according to BS 476 22 for timber doors in order to help retain a significant body of test data, to safeguard product availability for UK customers, and to protect vital overseas markets which have become particularly important for many UK door hardware manufacturers and suppliers, and are a great British export success story.”

Read the full GAI response to the DLUHC consultation on the removal of National Classes from Approved Document B on the GAI website at www.gai.org.uk/advocacy

Featured News

Specification news
Full Roofing Package — Gloucester Rugby Club

This project involved the supply of a full roofing package for Gloucester Rugby Club,...

Read More >>

Specification news
Five construction trends to watch in 2027

Experts featured in the latest episode of MEDITE SMARTPLY’s Beyond the Board...

Read More >>

BUILDING PRODUCT LIBRARY - LATEST BROCHURES

Valley Through Range Brochure

Valley Through Range
By Filon Products Limit...

Download Now >>

Safer Replacement Starts Below. Filon Fixsafe. Brochure

Safer Replacement St...
By Filon Products Limit...

Download Now >>

A Smart Way to Refurbish Profiled Roofs. Over-Roofing. Brochure

A Smart Way to Refur...
By Filon Products Limit...

Download Now >>

Site Assembled Rooflights & Specialist GRP Sheets Brochure

Site Assembled Roofl...
By Filon Products Limit...

Download Now >>

Factory-Assembled Multi-Layer GRP Rooflights Brochure

Factory-Assembled Mu...
By Filon Products Limit...

Download Now >>

BUILDING PRODUCT DIRECTORY - LATEST PRODUCTS

Magply multi-functional board
Magply multi-functional board

Rainscreen CladdingAs a high performance, multi-functional board Magply features a Magnesium...

Read More >>

Magply recovery and protection boards
Magply recovery and protection boards

Magply recovery and protection boards have been developed to meet the roofing industry needs for a...

Read More >>

Safeshield XT Reflect
Safeshield XT Reflect

Safeshield XT Reflect is an A2-s1, d0 fire rated construction membrane for the use in high risk,...

Read More >>

CONSTRUCTION VIDEOS - LATEST VIDEOS

Introducing the all-new weberpral E
Introducing the all-new weberpral E

A high-performance monocouche render with 22% lower carbon emissions from fossil fuels* - helping...

Watch Now >>

Fortitude™ Steel Railing Systems: Adjustable Off-the-Shelf Balustrade Guide
Fortitude™ Steel Railing Systems: Adjustable Off-the-Shelf Balustrade Guide

Fortitude Steel Railings and Balustrades are one of the most versatile, off-the-shelf, steel...

Watch Now >>

Pro-Railing® Stainless Steel Handrail Systems: 6 Modern Balustrade & Glass Railing Solutions
Pro-Railing® Stainless Steel Handrail Systems: 6 Modern Balustrade & Glass Railing Solutions

Pro-Railing® – our Stainless Steel Handrail Component System with six stunning ranges to choose...

Watch Now >>